Did the Diamondbacks do enough this offseason to turn their luck around? After a disappointing 80-82 season, the Arizona Diamondbacks had their work cut out for them heading into the 2026 offseason. While they didn’t splash the cash like they did in previous years, the team still made some notable moves over two months to reshape their roster. But here’s where it gets controversial: USA Today’s Bob Nightengale gave them a mere C- in his National League offseason grades, leaving fans and analysts divided. Was it a fair assessment, or did the Diamondbacks deserve more credit? Let’s dive in.
The Diamondbacks certainly didn’t sit idle. They re-signed Merrill Kelly to a one-year, $20 million deal after trading him to the Texas Rangers in July, a move that adds much-needed stability to their starting rotation. They also pulled off a big trade, acquiring former Gold Glove third baseman Nolan Arenado to replace Eugenio Suarez, addressing a glaring hole in their infield. Additionally, they took a chance on starter Michael Soroka and brought back backup catcher James McCann. These moves signal a clear intent to compete, but is it enough?
And this is the part most people miss: while the Diamondbacks made strides in some areas, their bullpen remains a major question mark. Their top two closers, A.J. Puk and Justin Martinez, are both recovering from elbow surgeries, with Puk expected back mid-season and Martinez not returning until late. In the meantime, the team will lean on Kevin Ginkel and Ryan Thompson, which could be a risky gamble. To bolster the bullpen, they’ve added low-risk options like Taylor Clarke, Shawn Dubin, Jonathan Loáisiga, and Derek Law, but will it be enough to hold down the fort?
On the bright side, the Diamondbacks did address their starting rotation depth, a critical need with Corbin Burnes sidelined until July. Signing Soroka and bringing back Kelly provides some insurance, though re-signing Zac Gallen remains a possibility, according to MLB Network’s Jon Heyman. Meanwhile, the outfield is a different story, with the team opting to give young players like Jorge Barrosa, Blaze Alexander, Jordan Lawlar, and top prospect Ryan Waldschmidt a chance to shine after trading Jake McCarthy and facing uncertainty around Lourdes Gurriel Jr.’s return from a torn ACL.
But here’s the million-dollar question: Did the Diamondbacks do enough to contend in 2026? While they’ve plugged some holes, the bullpen and outfield still raise concerns. A C- grade might feel harsh to some, but it reflects the team’s incomplete offseason checklist. What do you think? Did Nightengale get it right, or did the Diamondbacks deserve a higher mark? Let’s hear your thoughts in the comments—this debate is far from over!
